You Put Yourself at #1. Google's AI Picked Your Rival.
You made a "best tools" list. You put your own tool at #1. Google's AI reads lists like yours now, so it felt like a smart move. Then we asked Google a simple question and watched what its AI did with one of these lists.
Google's AI used the list, then picked someone else
Alloy Software sells help desk software. On its blog, it has a list of the 10 best help desk tools. Its own tool, Alloy Navigator, is #1. Freshservice is #2.
On October 7, we searched "best help desk software" on Google in the US. We did it twice. Both times, Google's AI Overview used Alloy's list as a source four times.
Then it named its picks: HaloITSM, Freshservice, Zendesk, Jira, Zoho Desk and a few more.
Alloy Navigator wasn't one of them. Not once.
So the list did its job, but for someone else. Alloy wrote the page, and HaloITSM and Freshservice got picked.
It's not just one company
Lily Ray is a well-known SEO expert. She has been warning about these lists all year. She tracks Google's AI answers for 100 "best software" searches. Her new numbers, from September, are rough news for brands that do this:
- Google's AI used 38% fewer "we're #1" lists than it did in June.
- When it did use one, it left out the brand that wrote it 83% of the time. In June, that was 69%.
- 70% of the time, the list helped a rival get picked instead.
In June, Lily Ray named five of these lists. We checked all five on October 7. Google's AI didn't use any of them anymore. It used Reddit, YouTube, PCMag, Zapier and Forbes instead.
Another study liked these lists a bit more. Scrunch looked at about 10,000 pages that AI tools used. A brand's own list did help a little. But the brand still got picked only about 7% of the time.
So who does Google's AI pick?
It picks the brands other people talk about.
Lily Ray compared the winners with the brands that got left out. The winners had far more websites linking to them and talking about them. Big brands can still put themselves at #1 and get picked. In one of our checks, LearnWorlds did. Lily Ray thinks Google gives big names like that a pass, because other sites already back them.
Google points the same way in its own guide. Its AI shows "what's being said about products and services across the web."
So a better list about yourself won't fix this. You need other sites to name you. Think reviews, guides and "best of" lists by real sites in your field.
One warning. Don't pay for those spots. Google calls buying links spam. Lily Ray says paid "mentions" are the new paid links. She also thinks a big Google update is coming soon.
The bottom line: your list can't vote for you. Other sites can.