Skip to content

Google Penalties: 79% of the Sites Hit Were Real Businesses [Investigation]

This week, SEO consultant Marie Haynes said requests for help with Google penalties went "from essentially no requests to several per week." Most, she said, come from real businesses. We wanted to see it for ourselves. So we read the penalty cases on Google's own help forum, one by one.

A Google Search Central Community thread: a software company asks for help with a Google manual action for thin content after removing 4,000 URLs
Screenshot: Google Search Central Community, thread by clickanalytic.com, captured 8 Oct 2026.

Who got hit

When a Google reviewer puts a penalty on a site, the owner sees a "manual action" in Search Console. Many of them then post on the Google Search Central Community asking for help.

We read the penalty posts there from May 19 to October 7. 22 out of 28 sites that shared their story were real businesses. 18 sell a product or service, and 4 are media brands. Five were sites built only to rank. One was a university.

Some of the real businesses:

  • ClearTax, a tax-filing platform in India with more than 8 million users.
  • Stream, a company that sells chat and video tools to app developers.
  • TestCoach, an exam-prep site run by the publisher S Chand. It was "completely de-indexed from Google Search."
  • Genex, a licensed blood-test lab in Dubai.
  • Jan Kohlenbach, a kitesurf teacher in Tenerife.

What Google went after

Most of these companies didn't lose their whole site. Google hit the part they built to get traffic.

NoBroker, a real-estate platform running since 2013, was hit on its blog and its moving guides only. Stream's penalty covered its blog, about 1,048 posts. Digital Nest, a marketing school, hired about 10 writers, some using AI tools, and put out about 170 posts in 4 months. Then: "Our main website pages are still ranking, but the blog traffic/visibility has dropped almost to zero."

ClearTax's problem was about 3,000 near-copy partner pages. PadhAI, an exam-prep app, was flagged for "scaled content abuse, off-topic pages."

The most common penalty was "Major spam problems," on 13 of the 28 sites. "Thin content" came next, on 6. Not one owner blamed an SEO agency in their post.

Three owners didn't cause their penalty at all. They bought a domain that was already penalized. Jan's kitesurf site has a "Pure spam" penalty "inherited from a previous owner."

Cleaning up doesn't make it go away

You'd think deleting the bad pages fixes it. It often doesn't. 12 of the 28 sites had a request to lift the penalty turned down at least once.

Click Analytic, a Swiss software company, removed about 4,000 URLs and cut its site to about 1,000 pages. "Google has just reviewed the site again and the manual action is still active." ClearTax cleaned up twice and was turned down twice. Jan has been turned down four times, for spam he never wrote.

Google's answers don't help much. At least three owners say the rejection used generic wording and gave no example pages.

The bottom line: these penalties are landing on real companies. Mostly they hit the pages made to pull in traffic: a blog that grew fast, template pages, a domain someone else ruined. If part of your site exists more for Google than for your customers, that's the part these penalties hit.

How we counted: we pulled the 4,000 most recent threads on the Google Search Central Community. 82 had a penalty in the title, posted May 19 to October 7, 2026. We read the first post of 58 of them before the forum blocked us for too many requests. 44 were owners asking about their own site, which makes 38 different sites. 10 of them gave too little detail to tell what kind of site it was, so we left them out. That leaves 28. "Real company" means a business that sells a product or service, or a media brand, checked against its live website.